Arrive Alive

Nutrition And Safety With Mushrooms

As summer approaches one of the many changes that occur in nature is the emergence of wild mushrooms.

The term “wild”, referring to mushrooms that have not been cultivated and have grown naturally.

One would expect to only find wild mushrooms in the” wild” as their literal name suggests, however they can pop up also most everywhere, even on grassy lawns in suburbia.

While the majority of mushrooms found in South Africa are not poisonous, the few that are have resulted in many fatalities over the years.

The consequences of eating the wrong wild mushroom range from dizziness to severe diarrhea and even death.

WHAT ARE MUSHROOMS?

A mushroom is the fleshy fruit bodies of several species of macrofungi (fungi which bear fruiting structures that are large enough to be seen with the naked eye). It is eaten like a vegetable, yet the part we eat is called a “fruiting body”, is neither a fruit nor a vegetable They can appear either below ground (hypogeous) or above ground (epigeous) where they may be picked by hand. Edibility may be defined by criteria that include absence of poisonous effects on humans and desirable taste and aroma.


Two small white mushrooms found on a hiking trip

THE DANGERS OF MUSHROOMS

Mushroom poisoning (also known as mycetism) refers to harmful effects from the ingestion of toxic substances present in a mushroom. These symptoms can vary from slight gastrointestinal discomfort to death.

 Mushroom poisoning is usually the result of ingestion of wild mushrooms after misidentification of a toxic mushroom as an edible species. The most common reason for this misidentification is close resemblance in terms of colour and general morphology of the toxic mushrooms species with edible species.

As EMS we have often treated entire families, who have ingested poisonous mushrooms that were used in a meal.

Mushrooms may also cause an anaphylactic or allergic reaction, where the body reacts to allergens present in the mushrooms which can trigger an allergic reaction.

In some instances mushrooms can also cause food poisoning.

PARTS OF A MUSHROOM AND IDENTIFICATION

Many field guides on mushrooms are available, but the ability to identify and prepare edible mushrooms is often passed down through generations.

The below picture shows the different parts of a mushroom, which are used to help identify a species of mushroom.


Source : https://sites.google.com/site/farmerbarter/024Mushroom.jpg

Many mushrooms are not easily identified and are often referred to as "Little brown mushroom" (or LBM) which refers to any of a large number of small, dull-coloured species, which are not easy to identify. As a result, LBMs typically range from difficult to impossible for mushroom hunters to identify


”LBM “ found In a back yard garden.

"Big white mushroom" (or BWM) is also sometimes used to describe groups of difficult to identify larger mushrooms.

USES FOR MUSHROOMS

The main attraction of mushrooms and the reason they are eaten is for their culinary value. Before assuming that any wild mushroom is edible, it should be identified. Proper identification of a species is the only safe way to ensure edibility. Deadly poisonous mushrooms that are frequently confused with edible mushrooms and responsible for many fatal poisonings.

Medicinal mushrooms are mushrooms or extracts from mushrooms that are thought to be treatments for diseases, yet remain unconfirmed in mainstream science and medicine, and so are not approved as drugs or medical treatments. Such use of mushrooms therefore falls into the domain of traditional medicine.

Only a few mushroom extracts have been tested for potential efficacy. Preliminary research results for most other extracts are on isolated cell lines, animal research with rodents, or early-stage clinical human trials as pilot studies.


a mushroom found on a camping trip

WHICH MUSHROOMS ARE SAFE TO EAT

Unfortunately, you can't learn from the taste or you might not live long enough to share your findings, is the jest of an old proverb regarding mushrooms. For your own safety, there must be no doubt in your mind that the mushroom you’re going to eat is safe to eat. While it would be impossible to in the context of this article say which mushrooms are safe to eat, the following points are good practice:

  • Only eat mushrooms you have positively identified yourself or by a mushroom expert.
  • Identify mushrooms a second time during preparation and cook them properly, unless you know that the species can be eaten raw.
  • Do not combine mushroom types.
  • Inform yourself about deadly mushrooms and those that are look-alikes of edible ones. "Deadly twins" differ regionally, so take into account regional variation.
  • Do not gather mushrooms that are difficult to identify, unless you have expert knowledge. This applies especially to the "little brown mushrooms" discussed earlier.
  • Consume only a small amount the first time you try a new species. People react differently to different mushrooms, and all mushroom species can cause an adverse reaction in a few individuals.

CHEMICALLY SPRAYED

To make the situation worse regarding the potential dangers of mushrooms, especially mushrooms that have grown in farm lands are often inadvertently sprayed with and or absorb chemicals and pesticides intended for crops and the pesticide residue can be instead, by humans from the mushrooms, which can result in illness.


two small mushrooms found on a town house lawn

MYTHS AND FOLK LAW

Humans have been eating mushrooms for hundreds of years and hence there are many myths about mushrooms and which are safe to eat. These same myths are a cause of many poisonings as relying on myths to help identify poisonous mushrooms is a dangerous strategy, as many of these myths are inaccurate and have no scientific basis.

Some unsafe, unreliable and untested myths include:

  • All white mushrooms are safe to eat
  •  Heating a poisonous mushroom and stirring it with a silver spoon or placing a silver coin on the mushroom, will turn the spoon or coin black
  • Any mushroom is safe to eat once thoroughly cooked
  • Insects can tell which mushrooms are poisonous and will avoid them. Not true!
  • Poisonous mushrooms taste bitter/sour/bad
  • All poisonous mushrooms have a pointed cap
  • Poisonous mushrooms will turn rice red when boiled with the rice

So unless you’re absolutely sure of the mushroom you have identified to eat, do not eat it, remember even experienced mushroom hunters have poisoned themselves.

MEDICAL ADVICE

  • If you are going to eat wild mushrooms be absolutely certain of the type of mushroom you are eating, it cannot be over emphasised enough. Base this decision on your knowledge of mushrooms and not on what folk law and myth say is safe to eat.
  • If eating a new mushroom type, only eat a little the first few time due to the possibility of anaphylaxis
  • If you in any way feel ill after consuming mushrooms seek medical help immediately, don’t wait to see if the signs and symptoms clear.  Signs and Symptoms may appear in a few minutes or be delayed for as long as 24 hours. Obvious Signs and Symptoms can include:
    • Nausea and vomiting
    • Dizziness
    •  Abdominal cramps and pains
    • Disorientation and confusion, with possible hallucinations

Conclusion

Mushrooms which are in fact a fungus have fleshy bodies, most of which can be safely consumed if correctly identified and prepared. The main attraction of mushrooms is for their culinary value, despite having little proven nutritional value. Some species of mushroom have toxins which can cause side effects ranging from gastrointestinal cramps to death. The most common reason of ingesting poisons mushrooms is the persons like of knowledge about mushrooms or inability to correctly distinguish the species of mushroom, which in the case of certain species require a person with expert knowledge and a microscope.

Article and photos by: Robert Mckenzie, Media Liaison Officer for KZN EMS

Also View:

Healthy Eating Driver Fitness and Safer Driving

Nutrition and Road Safety

References used in article

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mushroom_poisoning

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mushroom_hunting

http://www.powerofmushrooms.com.au/health-nutrition/health-nutrition/myths-facts/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mushroom_hunting

Loading...

Search Road Safety Articles

Latest Pages

Child Restraints and Road Safety

Child Restraints and Road Safety

Introduction to Child Restraints and Road Safety Increasing motorization worldwide has brought more crashes and injuries to vehicle occupants, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. One of the most effective measures to protect occupants from injury in the event of a crash is the fitment

Read More

Car Seats for Children and Road Safety in South Africa

Car Seats for Children and Road Safety in South Africa

Introduction: New legislation in South Africa is addressing a void that has for a number of years frustrated all those so deeply concerned with the safety of our children on the roads. The void referred to was specifically with regards to child passengers [infants] younger than 3 years old. Although

Read More

Promote buckling up and save a child’s life - A Medical Perspective

Promote buckling up and save a child’s life - A Medical Perspective

Introduction Despite Legislation requiring passengers to be Buckled Up, too many South Africans still fail to ensure that all passengers are safely secured inside their vehicles. Transport authorities, with the assistance of corporates such as Imperial, have gone to great lengths to create awareness

Read More

Imperial - your "Gateway to Africa"

Imperial - your "Gateway to Africa"

Imperial launched its milestone 'Gateway to Africa' campaign in July 2021. It is Imperial's strategic intent to become a 'One Imperial' business and serve as the 'Gateway to Africa' to its clients, principals and customers. The strategic decisions and actions the Group continues

Read More

Motorcycle Safety and Riding in Winter and on Icy Roads

Motorcycle Safety and Riding in Winter and on Icy Roads

On the Arrive Alive Website, with the assistance of the Motorcycle Safety Academy, we have shared information with our bikers on some of the techniques required for driving in bad weather. There are also some rather unique seasonal challenges as we approach this bitterly cold time of the year. We

Read More

Packing The Vehicle Safely For The Road Trip

Packing The Vehicle Safely For The Road Trip

Planning the Journey What you will pack for the road trip and how you will pack depends on how far you are to drive and the reason for your travels. There is a multitude of factors affecting the roadworthiness of your vehicle. These include tyre pressure, suspension, visibility through the windscreen,

Read More

Load More Pages

Partners

View All