Arrive Alive

Automobile Association (AA) welcomes the judgment on AARTO

 
The Automobile Association (AA) welcomes the judgment handed down by the Pretoria High Court declaring that the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences Act (AARTO), and its Amendments, are unconstitutional.
 
The court found that "the AARTO and Amendment Acts unlawfully intrude upon the exclusive executive and legislative competence of the local and provincial governments respectively and as such, the two Acts are unconstitutional."
 
The court also disagreed with the Minister of Transport's contention that any declaration of invalidity should be suspended for 24 months while Parliament rectified the Acts. The court found that were this to be permitted, then the system as a whole "...would not be able to give effect to the main objective of the statute...".
 
The AA says the judgment vindicates its position stated over many years that the AARTO Act was drafted without sufficient care. 
 
"As early as a few months after the 2008 launch of the AARTO pilot project in the Johannesburg and Tshwane Metros, the shortcomings of the Act became clear in practice. Attempts to rectify these shortcomings only created further issues, and now a court has found that the Department of Transport, in drafting AARTO, did not consider the fundamental issue of whether the system passed constitutional muster," notes the AA.
 
The Association, which has previously described AARTO as unworkable and geared towards revenue collection instead of promoting road safety, says it has been a vast waste of taxpayers' money which had done nothing to remedy South Africa's shocking road death rate. 
 
"There is no evidence that the AARTO pilot project has saved a single life," says the AA.
 
The AA also says that no purpose could be served by going back to the drawing board. 
 
"AARTO was assented to in 1998, and its design started much earlier. The court itself has found that the deficiencies are not curable. After almost a quarter of a century of failure, the government would be wise to concede defeat," it said.
 
The Association re-iterated its previous stance, which is that traffic fines should be dealt with in terms of the Criminal Procedure Act (CPA), with some legislative amendments to protect motorists in cases where delivery of fines and service of summonses was not conducted in accordance with the law.
 
A points-demerit system, which is one of the keystones of AARTO, could, according to the AA, be implemented as part of the judicial process. 
 
"This is how points-demerit has been implemented in other parts of the world for half a century or longer. The AA itself called for such a system as long ago as 1963, and we would be willing to work with government to help create it, just as we have assisted in developing many other aspects of traffic law," notes the Association.
 
Addressing one of the major consequences of the judgment, the AA says that the Road Traffic Infringement Authority (RTIA), which administers AARTO, would automatically cease to exist noting that, "the RTIA is a creation of the AARTO Act itself. Without the Act, the RTIA is a nullity”. 
 
"This would be a welcome step. For years the RTIA has acted outside all reasonable bounds. The Fines 4 U court case showed how the RTIA could abuse the conflicts of interest inherent in AARTO, and the RTIA's recently-dismissed previous Chief Executive, Japh Chuwe, along with other senior managers, was implicated in serious maladministration," the AA adds.
 
"AARTO and the RTIA have added no value to road safety and merely provided secure and lucrative employment for a select few. As such, we welcome the court's decision as a landmark in good governance in South Africa," the AA concludes.
 

Loading...

Related Articles

Woman Jumps From Moving Vehicle: Canelands - KZN

Woman Jumps From Moving Vehicle: Canelands - KZN

A 42-year-old female jumped out of a moving vehicle after her airbag was deployed while she was traveling on New Glasgow Road in Canelands, KZN a short while ago (Thursday). Members of Reaction Unit South Africa (RUSA) were dispatched to the single-vehicle accident at approximately 15:03. On arrival,

Read More

Bakkie rollover leaves one dead, another critical on the N1 highway in Barrage.

Bakkie rollover leaves one dead, another critical on the N1 highway in Barrage.

Last night, a man was killed and another critically injured when their bakkie rolled on the N1 highway in Barrage. ER24 and the Free State EMS arrived at 19h05 to find a bakkie on its roof on the side of the road. Two men were found lying trapped inside the vehicle. ER24 medics had to use specialised

Read More

Road fatalities rise again

Road fatalities rise again

The number of road fatalities during the 2021/2022 festive period were released: 1 685 people died on the country’s roads between 1 December 2021 and 11 January 2022. This is a 14% increase compared to the same period the previous year. According to the Minister of Transport, Fikile Mbabula,

Read More

Male suspect in possession of suspected stolen property including an airsoft rifle arrested in Paarl

Male suspect in possession of suspected stolen property including an airsoft rifle arrested in Paarl

Whilst on patrol in Paarl, armed response officer Farmer noticed suspicious activity by a male carrying bags in the area. As soon as he noticed the Fidelity ADT vehicle he became very nervous and changed direction. Officer Farmer approached the male to investigate. It was discovered that the male

Read More

Road Traffic Legislation Update

Road Traffic Legislation Update

The Minister of Transport has published the Road Traffic Management Corporation Regulations, 2022 in Government Gazette 45738, in notice NO. 1671 on 14 January 2022. The gazette regulates the fees for RTMC services as well as convenience fees for the application and issue of certain documents in terms

Read More

A suspect was captured on camera robbing a home in Selcourt

A suspect was captured on camera robbing a home in Selcourt

A suspect was captured on camera robbing a home in Selcourt yesterday, due to the fast reactions of Fidelity ADT the suspect was chased down and apprehended. The suspect was seen breaking into an unlocked garage in the area and stealing various tools. Warning to customers to please always remember

Read More

Load More Articles

Partners

View All